When choosing a bathtub for your bathroom, there is a lot of debate over whether to choose from an Acrylic vs Cast iron tub.
Both offer equally reliable results; for instance, in our experience using both types of tubs. Durability is not really an issue as most of the time it will be the wear and tear from day-to-day use that causes problems in the first place rather than accidental damage.
Where you may find more difference is when looking at aesthetics and one’s choice would depend on personal preference. Black polymer baths are popular however if you liked the look of an old-fashioned Victorian (like us), then antique cast iron baths might suit you better.
When deciding on the right sink for your bathroom, there are a ton of decisions to make. If you’re like me and many others, choosing what bathtub you want is one very important choice you have to make before getting busy with any other parts of your bathroom remodel.
There are two kinds of tubs. The first one is acrylic, and the second one is cast iron.
When deciding between Acrylic vs Cast iron tub, there are several factors to consider.
Bathtubs come with different benefits. These tubs have their own strengths and weakness but it’s important to understand what the pros and cons are before making a purchase.
EPDM rubber bathtubs are very hydrophobic, resistant to tearing, can be used in wet or dry areas, and have stronger tensile resistance compared to natural latex.
Polymer bathtub liners are strong, durable, and lightweight and can be used for a period of time.
Bathtubs get a lot of use over their lifetime, which is why you should invest in one that meets your needs.
Made from polycarbonate, acrylic bathtubs are valued because they are affordable, lightweight, come in many colors, and are resistant to chipping or cracking.
Compared to cast iron tubs which must be placed on a lower floor for added stability, acrylic tubs can literally be placed on any level of a house with ease.
What is Cast iron Tub?
Bathtubs are made from different materials, ranging from plastic to cast iron. Two popular materials are cast iron and acrylic, with the latter being more widely used in newer homes.
However, some consumers still opt for the strength and durability of a cast-iron bathtub because it is also best for a vintage look in bathroom décor.
Both types have their own advantages and disadvantages but ultimately the choice depends on aesthetic preference and budget constraints.
If you would like to install a new tub in your home, we recommend going for the cast iron option. Not only does it offer a classic modern look with some vintage appeal, but it is also worth the price.
These tubs also come in different color options. But, one thing I noticed while browsing cast iron bathtubs was they are much heavier than acrylic ones.
Adding weight to your bathroom tub can pose a problem if the area isn’t strong enough to support this excess load.
Cast iron bathtubs advantages:
- Cast iron tubs can withstand heavy impact without easily degrading.
- Cast iron tubs have excellent heat retention.
- Modern and vintage designs are available in a variety of colors.
- Paintable and refinish able
- Different styles are available to pick from.
- Can withstand a shower
- Long-lasting and durable
- Increases the resale value
- When bathing, it retains heat.
Cast iron bathtubs Disadvantages
- If put on an upper floor, the tub’s weight needs additional support.
- Tubs made of acrylic or fiber glasses are more pricey.
What is the Average Cast Iron Life Expectancy?
Tubs that are cast iron have a very long lifespan. To keep your tub looking and functioning beautifully, stick with regular cleaning.
You can ask the pros at Home Depot to tell you which cleaners work best on different surfaces, like porcelain or fiberglass.
If these tub receives proper maintenance and cares cleaning it with non-abrasive bleach-free cleaners, it will likely last between 10 to 15 years.
There are also other tips to keep the tub in tip-top condition such as keeping proper water pressure in the pipes installed under your bathroom floor.
The better the water pressure, the less frequently you need to use chemicals on build-up and deposits.
What Benefits Do Cast Iron Bathtubs Offer?
If you want a bathtub that will last the test of time, cast iron isn’t a bad idea. Many people think that these kinds of tubs need a lot of maintenance, but in reality, all they require is regular cleaning with just a cloth to maintain their looks for years.
These tubs have been around for generations and have sustained thousands and have never let anyone down. Not only are they an excellent choice if your bathroom has hard water stains to contend with, but also if you’ve got kids running amuck. Their durability is second to none!
If you’re looking for a bathtub that will keep you from getting sick, look no further than cast iron baths. These tubs are built around 3/8” thick and so durable you’ll never have to buy another one again.
Their superior durability holds up well against beating just about anything else that would leave dents, dings, or scratches.
What is Acrylic Tub?
The acrylic wall-mounted tub is probably the most popular because it’s lightweight and quite affordable compared to other tub varieties.
Its non-corrosive and does not need any extra support beneath the tub for installation purposes. As a previous owner of an acrylic bathtub, I found them to be very easy to clean; they come in various styles and patterns, ranging from modern to more of a vintage look if desired.
Acrylic wall-mounted tubs are a popular choice within freestanding bathtub installations or additions to a bathroom as one primary or secondary fixture.
If you’re looking for a freestanding would be the one that doesn’t need any specific type of installation, since acrylic tubs are pretty lightweight.
These are easy to clean and don’t require too much upkeep or cleaning. You can get them in a variety of colors that vary from modern to a more classic vintage style.
They are probably the most common type when it comes to these kinds of rectangular freestanding bathtubs.
Is it true that acrylic tubs can retain heat?
A marble tub may be wonderful for its appearance, but it does not keep heat in as well as an acrylic one does.
Compared to cast iron tubs, an acrylic tub can hold up to the competition and maintains water’s warmth longer than some other materials. If you love taking long hot baths, consider a higher-end acrylic tub for the best results.
Average Life Expectancy of an Acrylic Tub
Acrylic tubs have an average lifespan of 10 to 15 years, although those who are used more frequently will likely break even sooner.
Acrylic makes up much of the drainage systems in chemical plants and other places that deal with harsh substances regularly.
Advantages bathtubs advantages:
- Different colors and styles are available to pick from.
- Cleaning and upkeep are simple.
- The price range that is within reach
- Lightweight and simple to set up
- Heat retention is excellent.
Acrylic bathtubs Disadvantages:
- It could not have the same luxurious feel as porcelain or cast iron.
- It’s possible that the tub will become stained, scratched, or hollow.
Conclusions: Cast iron vs Acrylic tub
We hope you enjoyed reading our Comparison guide about Acrylic vs Cast iron tub. We hope this post helps you feel more confident about approaching a new bathtub purchase or repair.